Skip to main content
Navigation Menu

Cereal Milk Pie

Prep Time:

1 hr

Cook Time:

10 min

Total Time:

1 hr 10 min

Servings:

12

Indulge in a unique twist on traditional pie with this Cereal Milk Pie, featuring a creamy filling infused with the nostalgic flavor of cereal milk, baked to perfection in a flaky crust for a delightful dessert.

Ingredients

How to make it

  • CEREAL MILK:

  • 1

    First make the cereal milk to be used in pie filling.

  • 2

    Measure out 3 ¼ cups of milk into a pitcher. Add 4 cups of Cap’n Crunch® Original and stir vigorously. Make sure all cereal is submerged in milk.

  • 3

    Let sit for 20-30 minutes. Make pie crust while cereal milk is steeping.

  • PIE CRUST:

  • 1

    Grind 3 cups of Cap’n Crunch® Original in a food processor (or crush up in a plastic bag), place in a medium bowl and set aside.

  • 2

    Melt 1/2 cup of margarine and pour into the crushed-up cereal, mix together thoroughly.

  • 3

    Press mixture into 9” pie pan, ensuring cereal is firmly up the sides and pressed into the bottom of pan. Place in freezer to set.

  • PIE FILLING:

  • 1

    Strain cereal milk through mesh sieve and measure out 3 cups for the pie filling.

  • 2

    In a medium saucepan, warm cereal milk over medium heat, almost to a boil. Set aside to cool for about 10 minutes.

  • 3

    Whisk up egg yolks in small bowl, set aside.

  • 4

    Whisk the dry ingredients (granulated sugar, cornstarch and salt) into the cereal milk. Cook over medium-high heat to thicken. Whisk continuously so as to not burn the mixture.

  • 5

    Temper the eggs by slowly stirring in a cup of the milk mixture into the egg yolks. (This keeps the eggs from scrambling when adding to the pot.)

  • 6

    Add the tempered egg mixture back into the pot while whisking. Cook and stir on medium heat for an additional 2-3 minutes. Custard should be thick and bubbling.

  • 7

    Remove pot from heat and stir in cubed margarine until melted in. Stir in vanilla extract.

  • 8

    Transfer mixture to bowl and cover with plastic wrap. Let chill on counter to room temperature.

  • 9

    Once mixture is at room temperature, pour into prepared pie crust and smooth top with spatula.

  • 10

    Cover pie and refrigerate overnight to set completely.

  • WHIPPED CREAM (OPTIONAL):

  • 1

    To make whipped cream, stir together the heavy whipping cream and confectioners’ sugar in a mixing bowl fitted with whisk attachment. Whip until soft peaks form.

  • 2

    Add in vanilla extract and continue whipping until stiff peaks form.

  • 3

    Top pie with whipped cream and cereal pieces as desired.

Is this recipe fire🔥 or do you have a way to make it better?

Let us know below!